Best primary schools in Scarborough

How this list works. Ranked by the percentage of pupils meeting the expected standard in reading, writing and maths at the end of key stage 2, averaged over up to the last three years and weighted by the number of pupils each year. Only years with at least 10 pupils count, and a school needs at least one such year to be ranked. Independent schools, special schools and alternative provision are not ranked because their results aren't comparable. Ofsted outcomes are shown alongside but are not part of the ranking. Full methodology.

How the top 8 have ranked since 2016/17

Place on this list each year, on its three-year average

Met the expected standard
#School 22/2323/2424/25 3-yr averageSince 23/24
1 Thomas Hinderwell Primary Academy. Place on the list: 12th in 2016/17, 13th in 2017/18, 15th in 2018/19, 8th in 2022/23, 2nd in 2023/24, 1st in 2024/25. 77%83%77% 79% ▲ 1
2 Cayton Community Primary School. Place on the list: 2nd in 2016/17, 3rd in 2017/18, 2nd in 2018/19, 3rd in 2022/23, 3rd in 2023/24, 2nd in 2024/25. 69%72%61% 67% ▲ 1
3 St Peter's Catholic Primary School - a Catholic voluntary academy. Place on the list: 1st in 2016/17, 1st in 2017/18, 1st in 2018/19, 1st in 2022/23, 1st in 2023/24, 3rd in 2024/25. 64%73%63% 67% ▼ 2
4 St Martin's CofE Voluntary Aided Primary School, Scarborough. Place on the list: 7th in 2016/17, 6th in 2017/18, 8th in 2018/19, 5th in 2022/23, 6th in 2023/24, 4th in 2024/25. 66%50%77% 64% ▲ 2
5 Gladstone Road Primary School. Place on the list: 15th in 2016/17, 14th in 2017/18, 16th in 2018/19, 12th in 2022/23, 8th in 2023/24, 5th in 2024/25. 59%60%69% 62% ▲ 3
6 Wykeham CofE Primary School. Place on the list: 17th in 2018/19, 18th in 2022/23, 17th in 2023/24, 6th in 2024/25. –45%80% 62% ▲ 11
7 Newby and Scalby Academy. Place on the list: 5th in 2016/17, 4th in 2017/18, 3rd in 2018/19, 2nd in 2022/23, 4th in 2023/24, 7th in 2024/25. 57%64%63% 61% ▼ 3
8 Hertford Vale CofE Voluntary Controlled Primary School, Staxton. Place on the list: 3rd in 2016/17, 2nd in 2017/18, 4th in 2018/19, 6th in 2022/23, 7th in 2023/24, 8th in 2024/25. 50%53%68% 58% ▼ 1
#School3-year average
1 Thomas Hinderwell Primary Academy Ofsted: Report card 2025: 2 strong, 5 expected 79%
2 Cayton Community Primary School Ofsted: Good (2015), confirmed 2024 67%
3 St Peter's Catholic Primary School - a Catholic voluntary academy Ofsted: Good (2024) 67%
4 St Martin's CofE Voluntary Aided Primary School, Scarborough Ofsted: Good (2014), confirmed 2024 64%
5 Gladstone Road Primary School Ofsted: Good (2023) 62%
6 Wykeham CofE Primary School Ofsted: Requires improvement (2023, before conversion) · 2 years of results 62%
7 Newby and Scalby Academy Ofsted: No overall grade (2025) 61%
8 Hertford Vale CofE Voluntary Controlled Primary School, Staxton Ofsted: Good (2023) 58%
9 Lindhead School Ofsted: Good (2013), confirmed 2022 54%
10 East Ayton Community Primary School Ofsted: Good (2024) 53%
11 Hackness CofE Primary School Ofsted: Requires improvement (2024, before conversion) · 2 years of results 50%
12 Scarborough, Overdale Community Primary School Ofsted: Good (2018), confirmed 2024 48%
13 Seamer and Irton Community Primary School Ofsted: No overall grade (2025) 47%
14 St George's Catholic Primary School - a Catholic voluntary academy Ofsted: Good (2023) 46%
15 Wheatcroft Community Primary School Ofsted: Good (2023) 46%
16 Scarborough, Northstead Community Primary School Ofsted: Requires improvement (2024) 46%
17 Friarage Community Academy Ofsted: Requires improvement (2024) 44%
18 Braeburn Primary and Nursery Academy Ofsted: No overall grade (2025) 40%
19 Brompton and Sawdon Community Primary School Ofsted: Good (2022) · 1 year of results 31%
20 Barrowcliff School Ofsted: Good (2023) 30%

Result: met the expected standard in reading, writing and maths. Source: DfE school performance tables to 2025; Ofsted inspection data.

Page updated 15 October 2026.